Consign your Magic cards with us
Sell your MTG cards for close to what they are worth, without listing, shipping or answering buyers yourself. You get 85% of the sale price, 90% on cards over $25.00, paid weekly.
How it works
- Send your list. Export your binder from ManaBox (or any app that exports CSV) and email it to axelsondylan@gmail.com. A typed list works too.
- We tell you what qualifies. Any card worth $2.00 or more. You get back a list of what we would take and roughly what each would list for.
- Hand them over. In person, or mailed sleeved and toploaded. We check condition when they arrive.
- We list and sell. Your cards go on this site, priced from TCGplayer market, with the same photos, grading and shipping as everything else.
- You get paid weekly. Every sale shows up on your statement with the price and your cut.
How that compares
| Way to sell | What you keep | Your work |
|---|---|---|
| Consign with us | 85% to 90% of the sale price | Send a list, hand over the cards |
| Store buylist | Usually well under market, paid on the spot | None after the sale |
| Sell it yourself on a marketplace | Sale price minus marketplace and payment fees | Listing, packing, shipping, buyer messages, disputes |
Buylists are fastest; selling yourself can net slightly more if your time is free. Consignment sits in between: close to full value, none of the work. Our guide to selling MTG cards goes through each option.
FAQ
How much do I get?
85% of what the buyer pays for each card, or 90% for cards listed at $25.00 or more. We list at or just under TCGplayer market, so a card listed at $40.00 pays you $36.00.
What is the minimum?
Cards worth $2.00 or more each. Cheaper cards are not worth the handling for either of us, and we hand them back.
When do I get paid?
Weekly, by Venmo or cash, with a statement listing every card sold, its sale price and your share.
Can I take cards back?
Yes. Unsold cards come back whenever you ask. Picking them up is free; if we mail them back, you cover the postage.
Who decides the price?
Prices follow TCGplayer market for the exact printing, finish and condition and refresh with every inventory update. If you want a floor on a card, tell us and we will not list it below that.
What if a card is lost or damaged while we have it?
We pay you your share of its listed price, as if it had sold.
Who grades the condition?
We do, against the TCGplayer standard, when the cards come in. If our grade differs from yours, we tell you before listing, and you can take the card back.